As I completed Indiana Jones and the Great Circle, I felt a wave of nostalgia wash over me, reminiscent of my emotions when Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade hit theaters in 1989. The iconic theme by John Williams played in the background, and I couldn’t help but tear up. This time, however, I wasn’t just a spectator – I was Indiana Jones himself, navigating through a thrilling adventure that left an indelible mark on my gaming experience.
When Bethesda and Lucasfilm announced the development of an Indiana Jones video game in 2021, I was ecstatic. As a lifelong Indy fan, I had never played a game that truly captured the essence of the franchise. Unfortunately, I had to wait five extra months for the game to release on PlayStation 5, as I don’t own an Xbox or PC. The wait was agonizing, especially after reading io9 editor James Whitbrook’s scathing review, which described the game as “torture” to play. His criticisms of the controls and combat left me apprehensive, wondering if this game would be another Crystal Skull debacle.
However, as I delved into the game, I realized that James’ complaints about the controls and combat were valid. The fistfights were uninspiring, and the button-mashing mechanic felt unfulfilling. Drawing a gun or stealing one from a Nazi only led to more trouble, as it attracted a swarm of enemies. But then, I had an epiphany – as an adventuring archaeologist in the 1930s, I wouldn’t want to engage in mindless combat. I would prioritize survival, sneaking around, and avoiding trouble whenever possible. By adopting this approach, I found that the game transformed into a more enjoyable and immersive experience.

The game’s narrative is where it truly shines, expertly capturing the spirit of the first three Indy films. Without giving away too much, Great Circle sees Indy traversing the globe to acquire ancient stones that hold the key to a powerful artifact. The title’s subtlety is a nod to the classic Indy films, much like Last Crusade, which also had an air of mystery surrounding its MacGuffin. The game masterfully blends elements from Raiders and Temple of Doom, creating an unforgettable experience.
The game’s design allows for exploration and creativity, with sections that offer complete freedom to roam and engage in combat or stealth. Other parts are more action-oriented, featuring set pieces that surpass even the most epic moments in the movies. The first-person perspective enhances the immersion, and Indy’s commentary on historical connections and his curiosity-driven nature make the experience even more authentic. You’ll use notes, images, and disguises to solve puzzles and document your findings, all while navigating the world with your trusty whip and fedora.

The game’s climax is both satisfying and epic, featuring a finale that would be jaw-dropping on the big screen. If Indiana Jones and the Great Circle were a movie, it would undoubtedly be the third-best Indy film, right after Raiders and Last Crusade. I must admit that I have a soft spot for Temple of Doom, but it stands out for its unique tone and style. Great Circle, on the other hand, is a masterclass in capturing the essence of the original trilogy.
